born in the usa meaning reddit

• born in the usa meaning reddit
• Blog
• About
• Tutorials

By and large what our ancestors did to the natives when they arrived here was heinous, to put it lightly. Popular posts. Reagan certainly never listened to the lyrics. An example is anti-antisemitism meaning hatred of Jews, while Arabs are also Semite but are not included in the hate.

Otherwise, I have no cultural identity. You could call yourself Native American but it would just confuse people and is an unnecessary qualification, you are either American or you are not.

The song is about a general dissatisfaction with the country framed from the reference of a Vietnam Veteran.



We'd just like to remind you of a couple of things. And I thought that Every Breath You Take was a cute song about eternal love. The first. I'm not sure if you are objecting to the first, the second, or both. It rests in the message of hope in the songs of a man so many young Americans admire: New Jersey's own Bruce Springsteen.". Thanks! Your thoughts/responses to the question can go … 67,850 users here now [ SERIOUS ] Rules: You must post a clear and direct question in the title. It seems like people born in the US are, on some level, not allowed to call ourselves "native," because our culture hasn't been here as long as some others. Any questions or concerns? "I've got my Sprite, I've got my Orange Crush", of course not silly, its celebrating the famous denver bronco's defense of the late 70's and early 80's, The first kick I took was when I hit the ground, You end up like a dog that's been beat too much, Till you spend half your life just covering up, Got in a little hometown jam so they put a rifle in my hand, Sent me off to a foreign land to go and kill the yellow man, Had a brother at Khe Sahn fighting off the Viet Cong. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! I do research I couldn't do in the USA with diverse colleagues, I get paid and treated as a civil servant instead of a student, my house is older than the US as a country, I can go to Paris for the weekend as it's 3.5 hours by train (or wherever else for the weekend), and my adviser gets upset if I don't take my full vacation time each year of about five weeks.

4.7k. User account menu. This will be helpful in this conversation as well as elsewhere. I resent the notion that people born in America are widely not "Native Americans." Hilarious, then, that so many politicians use it. He gets a job at a factory which burns down and leaves him without any options.

Plenty of room in that box! You are American, descended from immigrants...just like 99.99% of all other Americans.

It is my opinion that, being born in America, into an American culture, I have as much right to call myself a native American (semantics and lack of clarity in the dual-use of the term aside) as anyone else. Everywhere. Is there a line? It's similar to NBC playing London calling during the olympics.

You have just as much (if not more) cultural identity as anyone else.

"Born in the U.S.A." is a song written and performed by Bruce Springsteen, and released in 1984 on the album of the same name. The upbeat-sounding chorus clashes against the lyrical content, so it's viewed by many as an ironic treatment of patriotism. You do have a cultural identity. I am not white, I am a shade of pink.

You make a good point and I can see why that would be the case in other colonial countries. You are approaching this wrong. hot new top rising.

193. hot. He comes home and the Veteran's Administration doesn't help him. same way you could refer to a bundel of sticks as a faggot, but if you shout to a group of people if they have seen a faggot they will likely misunderstand. Press J to jump to the feed. I might be missing a lyric or two, thats off the top of my head. Reddit is a network of communities based on people's interests. They had a home and a culture apart from the place they invaded. You learn something new every day; what did you learn today? "American Indian" is still preferred by most U.S. citizens who identify as indigenous, so if you object to "Native American," feel free to use "American Indian.". CMV, if you can. It's a song about the death of the American Dream and the big lie of serving in the military. I took origin to mean where your ancestors were from. The cultural identity of America is a nation of immigrants who have come to this country for a better life (blah blah blah).

It's great! That self-identification as immigrants is basically baked into your national consciousness.

To say you have no cultural identity if you are not allowed to use the term Native is quite strange to me. Archived.

This was sparked by this post on the front page today.

Lyrically it tells a really dark story addressing the mistreatment of veterans returning from Vietnam.

It's just that your cultural identity stems from the great experiment, the melting pot, that your country was founded by immigrants from all around the world. If you are thinking about submitting a CMV yourself, please have a look through our popular topics wiki first.

New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Additionally the existence of "Native Americans" and the exclusion from that group of everyone without indigenous ancestry is not exclusive to America. native is now considered a word denoting Indians in when mentioning amaricans but you are correct that you could use the word, i just wouldn't because while you may consider it the same the word association no longer puts that meaning as primary . that figure cited in the original quote is stupid. The native part in the former implies native lineage, the latter implies you were born in America and therefore are native of the country. It seems like people born in the US are, on some level, not allowed to call ourselves "native," because our culture hasn't been here as long as some others.

Well at least we all know "Lola" and "Crash into me" are about. It is my opinion that, being born in America, into an American culture, I have as much right to call myself a native American (semantics and lack of clarity in the dual-use of the term aside) as anyone else.

A place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the issue. >As of 1995, according to the US Census Bureau, 50% of people who identified as indigenous preferred the term American Indian, 37% preferred Native American, and the remainder preferred other terms or had no preference. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. How long will we have to exist before it's not weird to say that a white person can be a "Native American?". I understand that we currently use the term to refer to the people who were here when Europe barged in and Manifest Destiny'd all over the damn place. Edit: I feel like that's what people want me to think.

I just think the politicians that use it, only do so for the hook and never listened to the song or payed attention to the lyrics. There are a couple of issues here - the concept and the wording. Happy CMVing! But being so far removed chronologically from that event, it no longer makes sense. However, do you not get the impression that it is looked down in some ways upon to think of America as our home and be proud of our cultural heritage? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Press J to jump to the feed. United States. Any country with a colonial history and an indigenous population employs this same semantic distinction. Log in sign up.

Find communities you're interested in, and become part of an online community! Native is usually deeper than just born in a place.

6 months ago.

Your culture does not stem from the traditions of the people who lived in north America before the immigrants came, your culture is a new one that has taken from European, African, and Asian cultures. Otherwise, I have no cultural identity. Same goes for the Boer descendants of South Africa, or most of the inhabitants of Brazil.
I am sure many indigenous peoples dont actually use the term Native but it is an accepted term all the same and by saying all natural born Americans are Native Americans just muddies the water and could rob indigenous peoples of their identity. This is a footnote from your moderators.

It would seem to me that by wanting to adopt the term Native you dont add to your own identity but take away from others. That's why we have a distinction between Native American and just American. TIL that Bruce Springsteen's "Born in the USA" is about the negative effects of the Vietam War on Americans, but is often misunderstood to be a patriotic or nationalistic anthem. No text is allowed in the textbox. Posted by 6 years ago. Colbert was making a joke because that figure cited in the original quote is stupid. Submit interesting and specific facts about something that you just found out here. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Of course, nobody ever actually listens to the lyrics, they just rock out to the chorus.

Hello, users of CMV!
That guy is implying that people who come from other bloodlines (other than white Americans) have lower IQ's by default not simply people from other countries. It has since been co opted by people using it as a patriotic song, which is indeed retarded. In fact, when the song (and album) were at the top of the charts, his campaign used the song and Reagan said, "America's future rests in a thousand dreams inside our hearts. CMV: If you were born in America, you're a native American. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. AskReddit subscribe unsubscribe 22,742,482 readers. Close. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the changemyview community. We do not, and we were born here. Another example is black and white. I think there are a lot of people who would disagree with that on the grounds of the fact that we haven't been here long enough. Springsteen may be my favorite musical artist of all time, and this may be the song that first drew me in to his music... but I still can't say I really appreciate the "Cool, rocking daddy" line. So long as there are Aborigines the non-indigenous inhabitants of Australia should not rightly be called Native Australians. Right, but I feel like there's a popular opinion here in the U.S. (how selfish of us to call ourselves America when there are tons of countries on the two continents; oh well, everyone knows what we mean when we say it, so it's not that big a deal) that the "melting pot" culture is inferior to a "pure" culture. That having taken this and that from all the different cultures that comprise us "dilutes" our culture and makes it something inferior to the "pure" ones. I am from Europe and I really can't figure out whether this is meant serionsly or if it is just satire.

Its difficult to misinterpret if you actually read them.

I'm not personally ashamed of that because I didn't have anything to do with it. The next thing you are going to tell us is that REM's Orange Crush isn't about the joys of having a nice refreshing pop on a hot day... AC/DC's Big Balls isnt about great ballrooms where I can wear beautiful gowns and dance?

I resent the notion that people born in America are widely not "Native Americans." You are a native of The United States, not of Native American lineage. Maybe the meaning of "Born in the U.S.A." is the distance between the grim verses and the joyous chorus.

I do, however, feel like there is a general sentiment that that descended-from-immigrants culture is viewed as inferior to the native one, that there's a lot of guilt baked in there for what our ancestors did and that I should be ashamed for only having that to fall back on. Press J to jump to the feed.

Otherwise, I have no cultural identity. So I checked the box for "white" and typed in "Scottish German Irish English Italian French". View entire discussion ( 10 comments) More posts from the Census community.

Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I mean, in Europe, some places changed hands every few hundred years, and yet they have strong cultural identities.

.

Angel Gomes Fifa 20 Value Career Mode, Adventures In Public School Ending, Shaw Theatres Paya Lebar Quarter, Indignation Movie, Tbs Racing Drones, Commercial Real Estate For Lease, Warm Ways Fleetwood Mac Meaning, Where To Place Clear Quartz In The Home, Lifer In A Sentence, Garcia Bonaventure Prediction, Scotiabank Centre Seating, Ben Godfrey Whoscored, Is Jiang Ziya Out, Adopt Me Pictures Of Pets, I Love You Always Forever Lyrics Betty Who, Post Office Clipart, Theater Screen Opening Music, Carrie Underwood - Just A Dream Lyrics, Hvað Heitir Mugison, Star Utsav Live, Now That's What I Call Music 2020, Duke Men's Tennis Twitter, Hustle Means, Fox Networks Group Subsidiaries, Fleetwood Mac - Spare Me A Little Of Your Love, Tuskegee Weather Today, Related Words For Rose, Meet The Plastics Animatic,